Best Italian food in Petaluma

Pizza so Good , it'll Drive you Mad

Welcome to The Mad Sicilian!

Situated at 203 North McDowell Boulevard Petaluma, CA 94954, The Mad Sicilian invites you to indulge in the true essence of Italy nestled in the center of Petaluma. Immerse yourself in a realm of extraordinary pizza, where each mouthful narrates a tale of heritage and flavor spanning across Chicago, Naples, and Sicily.

HOLIDAY CANNOLI KITS

Wow, The holiday season is upon us! Due to popular demand, the Mad Sicilian is excited to announce that Cannoli Kit orders are NOW open! This season, choose from Original, Pumpkin Spice, or Turtle flavors. Each kit comes with 15 small shells, your choice of cannoli cream, and all the extras to create your delicious dessert. And the best part! Each kit is just $23! Place your Cannoli Kit orders from Nov. 22 to 24, with pick-up scheduled for Wednesday, Nov. 27, from 2 to 8 PM. No delivery.

Order Online

NEW HOURS

THURSDAY 3 PM - 8 PM; FRIDAY 3 PM - 9 PM; SATURDAY 2 PM - 9 PM; SUNDAY 12 PM - 8 PM; CLOSED MONDAY, TUESDAY, WEDNESDAY

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Original Cannoli

A traditional Sicilian pastry shell filled with rich cannoli cream, covered in decadent chocolate and crispy almonds, and topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar. This beloved recipe has been passed down through my family for years, stemming from my fondest childhood recollections. Each purchase includes three charming mini cannoli for your pleasure.

Add Item

Mamma's Italian Meatballs

The tender meatballs in our zesty marinara sauce are gently simmered, lightly topped with mozzarella and fresh Basil making them the ideal complement to your pizza.

Add Item

Zorbas Salad

The Mad Sicilian's unique take on a Traditional Greek salad includes fresh romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, bell peppers, red onion, English cucumber, kalamata olives, and feta cheese, all tossed in George's homemade Greek dressing for a delicious twist. Opa!

Add Item

Luciano

Experience the taste of Sicilian craftsmanship with our exquisite artisan pizza! Indulge in the mouthwatering flavors of our famous Napolitana crust, our zesty pizza sauce. Topped with fresh arugula, mozzarella, and capicola, each bite is a burst of flavor. And to add that extra touch of magic, we sprinkle our secret Sicilian blend. Prepare to be amazed by the divine combination of flavors!

Add Item

The Mad Sicilian: The Flavor of Madness

Experience a pizza that goes beyond the ordinary vegetarian fare. Our Napolitana Pizza features a delightful combination of sundried tomatoes, Kalamata olives, house-roasted garlic, and roasted red peppers, all finished off with a sprinkle of fresh basil.

Add Item

Authentic Chicago Style Cheese

Indulge in a mouthwatering deep dish pizza that will whisk you away to the vibrant streets of Chicago. This pizza is loaded with an abundance of cheese, making it an absolute delight for cheese lovers. If you're feeling adventurous, you can also customize your pizza with a variety of toppings, creating a truly unforgettable culinary experience!

Add Item

Club Lucky

One of the most beloved pizza combinations for the whole family is Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, and Black Olives. It's a classic choice that never fails to satisfy everyone's taste buds! Check out this picture of the uncooked Chicago Style pizza to see all the delicious toppings waiting inside! Deep Dish pizzas might need around 45 minutes in the oven to bake perfectly.

Add Item

Pazza Pizza

The Classic Cheese Pizza can be transformed to your greatest pizza creation. Enjoy it as Cheese pizza or use our amazing Napolitana Style crust, a hand tossed blank canvas ready for your masterpiece. Add toppings as desired. You should know that this may become an addictive habit.

Add Item

Palermo

Try our incredible Napolitana Style pizza, with a hand-tossed crust that's simply irresistible. It's loaded with mouthwatering toppings like Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Red onions, and Black Olives. This classic combination is a timeless favorite that you won't be able to resist!

Add Item

Mount Volcano

Indulge in a one-of-a-kind take on a traditional favorite with The Mad Sicilian's rendition of The Hawaiian pizza. Featuring a Napolitana crust topped with pepperoni, capicola, pineapple, green onions, and jalapeño, this combination offers a delightful blend of sweet and spicy tastes. Prepare to fulfill your appetite in a whole new way!

Add Item

November's Pizza SANTORINI

Order

Food, Family, Friends, Fun

The Mad Sicilian is a unique destination where the love for pizza, family, friends, and a touch of amusement come together to create unforgettable moments while indulging in exceptional cuisine. It stands as the ultimate dining spot for pizza enthusiasts and for those moments when family arrives, hugs are given, laughs are abundant and a fantastic meal is shared. For those moments are some of life's best memories.

What's in your Chicago Style Pizza??

A different kind-a pizza! Not your typical thinner crust, fold-in-half with one hand and chow down pizza! NO! This is a True Pizza Pie! A sit down with a fork and knife, dive-in to all that melted cheese and savor kind-a pizza! Now, we start with a basic cheese and sauce pizza; however, you may stuff your pie as desired! Just an FYI... In the windy city, Italian Sausage and Cheese is the Most popular pizza combination; if you are a traditionalist.

Mafia Speakeasies

Dive into our Authentic Deep Dish Chicago Style pizza, which pays homage to the notorious Mafia Speakeasies of the Prohibition era. We’ve crafted some awesome flavor combos that blend the unique with the classic, making it easier for those who are overwhelmed by decision making! And if you’re really struggling, why not treat yourself to two? Go ahead, indulge a little—you deserve it! Photos: 1) The incredible cheese pull from our Chicago Style Pizza 2) Club Lucky 3) Gioco 4) Green Door 5) The Green Door is topped with our homemade Creamy Pesto 6) Lottie's Pub 7) Room 21 8) The 226 Club 9) Twin Anchors ...these images showcase our uncooked pizzas, brimming with toppings for our Chicago Deep Dish. The final product usually resembles photo 1, complete with that mouthwatering cheese pull!

Meatball Madness - 🏈 AUGUST 15 🏈

Dive into the Meatball Madness at The Mad Sicilian! Cheer on your team with our tasty meatball appetizer. Every NFL Game Day gets better with our scrumptious meatballs, making them a must-have for your Game Day hangout. For a short time, grab some free meatballs when you spend $45 or more. You definitely don’t want to miss this awesome offer! Begins AUGUST 15

Order

A Taste of Italy

Our menu boasts an array of classic Italian dishes that will take you to the bustling streets of Rome or the serene countryside of Tuscany. From flavorful pasta dishes to mouthwatering pizzas, each plate is crafted with care, ensuring an authentic culinary experience with every bite.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

Convenience at Your Fingertips

In today's busy world, convenience is key, and we've got you covered. Whether you're craving a cozy night in or need to feed a hungry crowd, our delivery, takeout, and catering services make enjoying our flavorful fare a breeze. Simply place your order online or give us a call, and let us take care of the rest.

Events

Holy Cannoli This incredible dessert is offered in a kit of 12 for your Special Event. Everything you need to impress your guest with a unique dessert that may be filled moments before serving or as an interactive crowd pleaser. Made from the family recipe passed down from my Grandparents steeped in Sicilian Tradition! Keep in mind, a 48 hour advance order is required.

Dine-In Experience

For those looking to soak in the ambiance and warmth of our restaurant, we invite you to dine in with us. Our casual atmosphere and friendly staff create the perfect setting for enjoying a leisurely meal for any occasion, whether you're hanging out with friends, having a family get-together, or enjoying a cozy dinner for two.

The Mad Sicilian Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

After Little Star, I never thought I'd fall in love with another deep dish pizza place, until Mad Sicilian. We've been getting deep dish from Mad Sicilian for a couple of years now. And it is for sure one of, if not, the best deep dish pizza in the Bay Area. Yes, better than Zachary's. For sure better than Patxi's. And sadly, as of late, better than Little Star. (Only because the last couple of times I went there, the quality seemed to have slipped). What makes it so good? The mountains of cheese stuffed inside this pizza. You can't tell right away because of the beautiful sauce on top. But it is loaded. And of course, the crust. Flavorful, slightly dusted with corn meal and brushed with an herb topping. It is sooo good. How much do we like it? We ordered Mad Sicilian for our wedding rehearsal dinner. You can tell that the owners love pizza, and they love THEIR pizza. They seem like the type of people who would never trade on quality. My wish is that they open a bigger location where there are more than 2 tables so that we can eat in more often. Being in Novato, the traffic deters us from going there to pick up a pizza and bring it back. But if there is a bigger location, we'd be okay with fighting traffic to eat in. Besides the deep dish, we've also had the sicilian which is also delicious with their herb coating all over the crust. Really yummy. And their service is also always excellent. Once the pizza was taking longer than expected, and they gave us some free dessert. You can just tell the owners want to take care of their customers and give them the best they can give you. I super appreciate that as well. Anyhow, if you like deep dish, give them a try! We've heard their regular pizzas are delicious too - but how do we not get the deep dish?!

Bonnie H

The Chicago style pizza was amazing with fresh ingredients. Staff was very attentive and friendly!

Tiffany S

My girlfriend and I were in Sicily last year and this restaurant brought us back in an instant. I recommend the deep dish pizza and Danza salad. So delicious!

David M.

Best pizza in Petaluma * Fantastic pizza! Very fresh ingredients with more than ample amount on each pizza. Just a little place with a few tables. Great people run this very authentic pizza place. This is our place to go for pizza in Petaluma.

SnmaGal

Great Pizza. Ordered the Deep-dish Chicago with Sausage. Incredibly fresh local ingredients. Full of flavor and worth the stop. The staff is friendly and dedicated to making the best pizza I have ever had. This is more than pizza but a culinary master piece!

Timothy H.

The pizza is delicious. We customized our own deep dish and it was very tasty. The sauce had great flavors and the crust was perfect . Service was quick and staff was friendly ! Highly recommend.

Melissa L

Best deep dish pizza ever * This is the best deep dish pizza I have ever had. The ingredients are fresh and the sauce is delicious. The garlic, cheese, and meat are in the perfect combination to make this the best ever

Bruce M

We decided to eat here after we saw a few highly rated yelp reviews and oh my they didn't disappoint! All my cheesey dreams came true! The tomatoes sauce on top was perfectly balanced! Don't forget to add roasted garlic!

Sunny F.

Me and my husband were out at Dillion beach, and on our way home (we live in the valley) we wanted some pizza so I googled pizza…and here we ended up! This place was delicious, the crust had so much flavor which blew us away. The sauce wasn’t too salty, lots of flavor and same for the meat! We got meatballs on the house, and we ordered their breadsticks. The owner made the ordering experience personable and checked on us multiple times, that was so refreshing and left s lasting impression on us. I would drive over an hour just to go eat there again, that’s for sure!

Brittney

Best pizza I have ever. Very nice people and again best pizza you can find. George really know what he doing. Salads also was outstanding.

Igor S

Went in today to try the pizza and it was amazing! We dinned in and ate the Ragusa. We also decided to bring Chicago style home. The Ragusa was phenomenal - I was with picky eaters and they rated it some of their favorite pizza! Even reheated, the Chicago style was amazing! All of the ingredients are flavorful and fresh. You could taste every ingredient with each bite. Chef George came out and talked with us which was so much fun! He is a fun, entertaining host and made our whole experience just wonderful! We will definitely be back to try more!

Shonna K

The best Chicago deep dish I've had ever! The tomato sauce was amazingly flavorful and complemented the richness of the cheese and pepperoni with its acidity and tang. Really amazing